Circulation of the subpolar North Atlantic: The image shows a snapshot of the surface velocity in the high-resolution VIKING20X model, showing the meandering flow of the North Atlantic Current and the narrow boundary current that develops south of the Denmark Strait along the eastern continental shelf of Greenland. Shaded in grey is the area where convection exceeded 1800 m depth during the winters of 1990-1994.

Simulated near-surface speed combined with ice cover from VIKING20X. Simulation: Klaus Getzlaff (Ocean Modelling Group, GEOMAR)

Schematic of surface (red) and deep (blue) currents in the Atlantic Ocean. Circles indicate regions where currents are strongly influenced by oceanic eddies. The dashed area between Canada and Greenland outlines the area in the Labrador Sea where strong winter cooling causes vertical mixing of the water column. Graphic: Böning / Scheinert (GEOMAR)

Winter storms over Labrador Sea influence Gulf Stream system

New study on Atlantic current variability published

03.08.2023/Kiel. The Gulf Stream system plays an important role in climate. The weakening of this system that has been observed over the last two decades is therefore a cause for concern and much debate. The question is whether the measurable changes are already due to human-induced climate change - model simulations predict such an influence with high probability for the future. A new study by scientists at the GEOMAR Helmholtz Centre for Ocean Research in Kiel, Germany, now published in the journal Nature Communications, concludes that the currently observed weakening can be interpreted, at least in part, as a natural fluctuation following some extremely cold winters in the Labrador Sea in the 1990s.

The Gulf Stream, which brings warm water from the Gulf of Mexico to Europe and keeps the climate mild, is only part of a larger system of oceanic currents called the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation, or AMOC for short. It runs through the Atlantic like a giant climate machine: as warm water from the tropics is transported northwards at the surface, the current reverses in the North Atlantic – the water cools, becomes heavier and flows south at depth.

Where exactly these sinking processes take place is the subject of current research, and recent measurement programmes have located them to the east of Greenland. A team of scientists from the GEOMAR Helmholtz Centre for Ocean Research in Kiel, Germany, has now conducted a modelling study of the Labrador Sea southwest of Greenland. In their study, now published in the journal Nature Communications, the researchers used complex computer simulations to show that fluctuations in the Labrador Sea can have a significant influence on the strength of sinking processes east of Greenland. An important link is a little-noticed system of deep currents that ensures the rapid spread of Labrador Sea water into the deep-sea basin between Greenland and Iceland.

"We oceanographers have long had our eyes on the Labrador Sea between Canada and Greenland," says Professor Dr Claus Böning, who led the study. "Winter storms with icy air cool the ocean temperatures to such an extent that the surface water becomes heavier than the water below. The result is deep winter mixing of the water column, whereby the volume and density of the resulting water mass can vary greatly from year to year".

In the model simulations of the past 60 years, the years 1990 to 1994 stood out, when the Labrador Sea cooled particularly strongly. "The unusually large volume of very dense Labrador Sea water that formed following extremely harsh winters led to significantly increased sinking between Greenland and Iceland in the following years," explains Claus Böning. As a result, the model simulations calculated an increase in Atlantic overturning transport of more than 20%, peaking in the late 1990s. The measurements of the circulation in the North Atlantic, which have only been carried out continuously since 2004, would then fall exactly in the decay phase of the simulated transport maximum.

"According to our model results, the observed weakening of the Atlantic circulation during this period can therefore be interpreted, at least in part, as an aftereffect of the extreme Labrador Sea winters of the 1990s", summarises Professor Dr Arne Biastoch, head of the Ocean Dynamics Research Unit at GEOMAR and co-author of the study. However, he clarifies: "Although we cannot yet say whether a longer-term weakening of the overturning is already occurring, all climate models predict a weakening as a result of human-induced climate change as 'very likely' for the future.

Ongoing observing programmes and further development of simulations are crucial for a better understanding of the key climate-relevant processes. And, of course, for future projections of the Gulf Stream system under climate change.

Original publication:

Böning, C.W., Wagner, P., Handmann, P. et al. (2023): Decadal changes in Atlantic overturning due to the excessive 1990s Labrador Sea convection. Nature Communications, doi: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-023-40323-9

A map of the North Atlantic with colour-coded ocean currents

Circulation of the subpolar North Atlantic: The image shows a snapshot of the surface velocity in the high-resolution VIKING20X model, showing the meandering flow of the North Atlantic Current and the narrow boundary current that develops south of the Denmark Strait along the eastern continental shelf of Greenland. Shaded in grey is the area where convection exceeded 1800 m depth during the winters of 1990-1994.

Simulated near-surface speed combined with ice cover from VIKING20X. Simulation: Klaus Getzlaff (Ocean Modelling Group, GEOMAR)
Scheme of the Atlantic Ocean with ocean currents in red and blue

Schematic of surface (red) and deep (blue) currents in the Atlantic Ocean. Circles indicate regions where currents are strongly influenced by oceanic eddies. The dashed area between Canada and Greenland outlines the area in the Labrador Sea where strong winter cooling causes vertical mixing of the water column. Graphic: Böning / Scheinert (GEOMAR)